ACAcamps.org Donate Bookstore Peg's blog Contact us Site map
Education
Camping Magazine
Current Issue
Digital Magazine
Subscribe
Archived Issues
Advertise
As Seen In . . .
Knowledge Center
CampLine
Conferences
Training / Prof. Development
Research
Start a Camp
 
 

Taking Stock of Summer 2008
In the Trenches

by Bob Ditter

From mid May until late July this summer I spent forty-three days in a camp somewhere in one of ten states in the United States. I boarded thirty-three airplanes, took six ferries, and drove over four thousand miles to be able to speak with paid and volunteer counselors, key staff members, directors, campers, and parents. I'd like to share a sampling of some of those experiences in this month's column.

Junior Counselors

We all know that the transition from camper to staff is a rough one. It seems that no matter how much you tell your junior counselors (JCs) that being a counselor is hard work involving personal sacrifice, they always seem like they've been hit by a truck called "reality" once camp begins. Given their deep personal love of camp and their potential for great camp spirit, it's worth the effort to cultivate these young people and help them develop into mature staff. Here are a few things I've learned about working more successfully with JCs that might help in that process:

  1. The best people to talk to JCs about their role as counselors and the transition they are about to make are successful, strong performing members of your staff who were themselves former campers and who have lived through the very transition the JCs are now facing. Not only do they have the most credibility with JCs of anyone on your staff, they know first hand just what the challenges of making the transition from camper to staff really are. They can offer advice that is more practical and more inline with what JCs will actually experience, and the chances that JCs might actually listen are greater when delivered by people with whom they can easily identify.
  2. Junior counselors experience a myriad of difficult feelings when they graduate from their camper careers and advance into the ranks of staff. Some of these include the following: a) In one quick summer they go from high status as the oldest campers to low man on the staff totem pole! This means they go from being the most celebrated, most visible group on campus to the least.b) They have to give up hanging out together as a group after having spent years developing an extraordinary closeness with one another. The truth is that many JCs come back to camp for their friendships more than anything else.c) Younger counselors are easily frustrated when campers don't listen to them, and they insist all the while that they "were never like these rude kids" when they were campers!d) They don't understand why their spirit and love of camp isn't enough to get them high marks as counselors. JCs need a chance to talk about these feelings and have them validated by senior staff members who care about their growth and well-being.
  3. Junior counselors, I have discovered, often have a concept of what it means to "work" with campers that is very different from their senior counterparts. Given that they are closer in age to campers than most other staff, many JCs identify more immediately with campers and are more tuned-in to their emotional and social struggles — sometimes too much so. Talking with campers about these social and emotional needs is what many JCs call "work." While they are often very good at connecting with campers, they often minimize the more physical tasks of being a counselor: like clean-up, which still needs to be organized; or laundry, which needs to be collected or distributed; the sunscreen that still needs to be put on; the tables that still need to be cleared; and the campers that need to get to activities on time. "We talk with the kids more than anyone and we understand them better, but we still get yelled at for not doing our jobs!" Sound familiar?
  4. Junior counselors need a compassionate, mature senior staff member to mentor and guide them through their first summer. This, of course, is only important if you want a program that actually develops increasingly skilled and capable counselors. This person — one whom the JCs respect and admire — should be in touch with JCs before they even come to camp (a separate camp "user page" for junior counselors on MySpace.com or Facebook.com dedicated to this very purpose is an ideal way to make and maintain this contact). This mentor should meet with them throughout orientation to set up expectations, facilitate a meeting with former campers-turned-counselors (see point #1), then follow up with regularly scheduled, summer-long meetings to talk about kids and the adjustment they are all making in their new role at camp. This well-respected senior player will need to validate all the losses and changes JCs legitimately experience (see point #2) while helping them develop ways to cope with the demands of their new role.
  5. When it comes to JCs, I have found that most camps confuse post-session evaluations with coaching. Both are forms of feedback, but giving feedback to anyone after their job is over doesn't allow them to benefit from that feedback while they still can make use of it. JCs more than others on your staff need more immediate and specific feedback about how they are doing in terms of their work ethic (being on time, being properly prepared, sharing responsibilities, pitching in, being where they are supposed to be); camper care (making sure campers are fitting in and making friends, attending to homesick kids, making sure their self-care needs are met); and following camp rules (making curfew, etc.).
  6. A major skill for JCs to learn is how to take critical feedback well. Learning how to accept and integrate thoughtful feedback into one's performance is a life skill. I find it is best to discuss the issue of receiving feedback with all the JCs in a group setting. In that discussion it is important to talk about how to keep things in perspective, how not to take things personally, and how to make use of the feedback one gets to make positive changes in one's performance. Learning to truly hear and evaluate feedback is a significant part of what JCs should learn in their first year as counselors as it is crucial to further developing into a better counselor.

Many camps have a junior counselor program without giving much thought to managing it well. Learning to "ratchet up" your program with innovative ideas will help you tap into the spirit and special energy of your JCs while helping them grow into more skilled staff members.

Poor Loser Camper

"Jason" is a nine-year-old camper most of us have probably met at some time in our careers. An avid competitor, Jason is a small wiry boy who loves to play games like basketball, ga-ga, and dodge ball. You could say Jason really throws himself into the game — sometimes literally! While Jason is a strong competitor, he gets very upset when a point or play doesn't go his way or when a team mate doesn't perform the way he thinks they should. When this happens, Jason has been known to push, swear at, or even hit his opponent — or his team mate — often getting himself ejected from the game as a result.

Most camp professionals would probably suspend Jason from the activity and explain the potential consequences of his behavior. They might even have a "strike one, strike two, strike three" set of escalating consequences for Jason's behavior. "Strike one" might be, for example, you sit out the rest of the game. "Strike two" might be getting banned from that game for the rest of the week or camp session. "Strike three" might be having to call his parents or even go home, depending on how egregious Jason's behavior is. Jason might even be remorseful and promise never to do it again, only to get caught up in the heat of the game and lose his temper once again.

So what do you do if the specter of these consequences — well-intentioned and reasonable as they are — don't make a bit of difference in Jason's behavior? What if this escalating set of consequences doesn't result in any learning on his part?

Sit Jason down and explain that you want to help him stay in the game and you need his help to do it. Tell him you are going to give him a wristband, like the "Livestrong©" wristbands many campers and staff wear these days, but one with a special meaning. This wristband will be his bright reminder to stop and count to ten before he gets angry in a game. Tell him that before each game you will give him the wristband to put on and that you will also put one on that is identical to his. When you give him that wristband, you will give him a little pep talk and tell him that if he gets upset, he should come to you for help in keeping his temper. You can then call "time outs" if you think Jason might need to calm down, and now Jason can feel like someone is there to help him. Tell Jason that you will be carrying a small 3- by 5-inch file card, and every time Jason "catches" himself, asks for help, or takes his own time out to cool his temper, you will give him a point. Once he gets a certain number of points he gets to do something truly special at camp, like get an extra water skiing period or play a special game, etc.

This is a synopsis of a scheme I tried this summer with several different kids with similar behavioral challenges at different camps, and it seemed to have a high success rate. The wristband is something the other kids don't really notice, since so many of them have one of their own anyway, and the point system on the "traveling" 3- by 5-inch file card (counselors hand it off to one another as Jason goes from place to place) gave "Jason" the kind of immediate feedback he needs to make a significant change. This little scheme also fits my maxim about changing behavior, which is that we can't expect children to stop doing something (in this case, losing his temper in often fierce ways) unless we give them something else to do in its place (ask for help, count to ten, cool off, etc.).

Parents and More

Early in the summer, I used the phrase "kidsick parents" to describe many parents today who have great difficulty separating from their children when they go off to camp. Much has been written about "helicopter parents" who hover over their children and are over-involved and don't allow their children to learn coping skills from the common pains and setbacks we all encounter in everyday life. In my next column, I will talk more about working with these parents and share other insights from the summer.

Let me leave you with one closing thought about parents, however. Parents give us their "best children" when they entrust them to our care. It is only right that we should give them our best personal and professional understanding of children in return, for it is only with this commitment to continued learning that we will retain the trust parents have in us and in camp. We owe them and their children — and camp as a whole — nothing less.

Originally published in the 2008 November/December issue of Camping Magazine.

Quick Links Connect with ACA
Find a Camp Membership Media Knowledge Center Twitter
Find a Job Accreditation Parents Camping Magazine Facebook
Donate Conferences Volunteers Education/Training YouTube
Bookstore Public Policy Peg's Blog e-Institute LinkedIn
Research Message Boards Buyers Guide ACA Logos RSS Feed
Contact ACA
National Office
Local Offices
Webmaster
About ACA
© 2009 American Camping Association, Inc.