Risk Management: Exploring the Concept of Risk

by Linda Ebner Erceg, R.N., M.S., P.H.N.

Most people can handle — or tolerate — a certain degree of risk. The edginess provided by risk adds verve to being human, and often gives us that gentle kick in the seat of our pants needed to prod us along in life. Risk tolerance, however, exists on a continuum. There are times when a person is more comfortable with risk than at other times. In addition, risk tolerance varies from person to person. Some thrive on the thrill associated with it, while others may be paralyzed.

Our camp world masterfully stages risk based on an individual's risk readiness. Beginning with the decision to come to camp, campers progress through swimming, archery, and other skills as readiness deepens. Even interpersonal skills are coached using techniques that help people expand their repertoire of risk-management skills.

Yet, every once in a while, camp professionals grapple with risks that present a challenge. These are especially impactful when the outcome of inadequate or inappropriate risk management makes a difference to the health and safety of people.

The Concept of Inherent Risk

Those who read articles by the recreational lawyers Charles R. Gregg and Catherine Hansen-Stamp recognize this concept. It's used to describe risks related to the nature of an activity. An inherent risk is impossible to manage or give away; doing so would change the nature of the activity.

Given this, the decision to attend camp typically presents inherent risks to one's health. One of the risks is the exposure participants have to the flora and fauna endemic to the camp's geographic area. Be it ticks, mosquitoes, bats, poison ivy/sumac, or the occasional skunk or sea urchin, it's impossible for a camp to eliminate exposure to these inherent risks. One might minimize the exposure, but eliminating it is impossible.

Another inherent risk, one associated with bringing people together for an experience like camp, is communicable disease. As experience with illnesses such as novel influenza H1N1, chicken pox, and the common cold has demonstrated, one can screen for communicable illness but screenings are no guarantee of protection. Humans interacting in community pass some illnesses from one to another; it is inherent to human interaction.

Why the Tension Surrounding Risk?

The tension surrounding risk in our camp world comes from two sources. One occurs when a client, often the parent of a camper, doesn't understand the camp's inherent risks and/or the notion that a camp's ability to protect a given individual's health status can only go so far. To combat this, camp literature could proliferate in an effort to include comment about everything. Perhaps, the better solution is to utilize the concept of inherent risk in combination with comment about risk reduction strategies. It's an idea worth talking about, especially with the camp's legal counsel.

The second tension arises from a camp's interest in minimizing risk, even inherent risks. This tension exists between doing what is reasonable and doing all that's possible. Strategies such as screenings, educating campers and staff, and utilizing tools like insect repellents and sunscreen, all help minimize risks, including some inherent risks. But these strategies are not sufficient to eliminate the risk. About the only way to totally eliminate risk would be to choose non-participation (not come to camp). Since this is not a viable option for most, we seek to position ourselves someplace in the middle, that place where risk reduction measures are utilized, acknowledging that the risk may be reduced but not eliminated.

Techniques That Minimize Risk

Writers in the field of risk reduction describe strategies commonly used to manage risk exposures (Coutellier, 2008; Robertson, 2007; Wilde, 1994). These techniques can be applied when addressing any risk, even inherent risks, and are as follows:

  1. Prevent the creation of the hazard. Camp professionals exercise this when they choose not to do an activity because it poses too much risk. Sometimes other entities — like insurance companies — impose this by refusing to insure things that exceed the company's risk tolerance (e.g., eliminate the diving board; no trampolines).
  2. Reduce the amount of the hazard. This strategy is used when the maintenance staff clear poison ivy from under clothes lines or along commonly traveled paths. It's not that they can eliminate poison ivy but they can reduce the amount of the hazard within the environment.
  3. Prevent the release of a hazard that already exists. This explains why combustibles are locked up and why some foods are maintained within a safe temperature zone. The hazard exists; one is controlling the release of that hazard.
  4. Modify the rate or spatial distribution of the hazard. This is why swimming occurs in a designated area rather than anywhere along the camp's lake shore, and why cabin beds are placed with at least 32” between sleeping heads.
  5. Separate, in time or space, the hazard from that which is to be protected. This is illustrated when walking paths are separated from motor vehicle driving lanes, or why people with contagious illness are isolated from the healthy population.
  6. Separate the hazard from that which is to be protected by a material barrier. Arm guards in archery, knee pads for volleyball, protective shoes in the kitchen and riding stable, and hearing protection at riflery all illustrate this point.
  7. Modify relevant basic qualities of the hazard. This explains why there are guard rails on bunk beds and lifeguards at the waterfront, why one keeps kitchen knives appropriately sharpened, and the reason for using a soft rather than hard ball for many games.
  8. Make what is to be protected more resistant to damage from the hazard. This strategy explains the reason for vaccinations, why campers condition or warm-up before some activities, why insect repellents and sunscreen are used, and provides rationale for swimming lessons.
  9. Begin to counter the damage already done by the hazard. Granted, this strategy happens after the fact; its value lies in protection from further damage. For example, it's why we're interested in getting first aid care to injured people in a timely manner, and it's why people learn CPR or how to use an AED.
  10. Stabilize, repair, and/or rehabilitate the object of damage. This is the reason for alerting maintenance staff to things needing repair, rotating fatigued people out for a rest, and periodically re-conditioning equipment or surfaces.

Challenging Risk Assumptions

Risk surveillance is a reality of life for most camp professionals. We intuitively see things needing attention and make a point of addressing that observation using the strategies just reviewed. Yet sometimes we neglect to consider risk from the perspective of our clients or staff, forgetting that they may need reminding of camp's inherent risks. And, we sometimes forget to challenge our own mindset: when is risk tolerable? To borrow from Wendy Mogel's message, when might there be virtue in that skinned knee?

Originally published in the 2010 January/February issue of Camping Magazine.

Your rating: None Average: 1 (1 vote)

Cleve air max stood where

Cleve air max stood where canada goose he pandora charms was louis vuitton till the uggs on sale step sac michael kors was cheap oakley sunglasses lost in nike blazer pas cher silence, michael kors and gucci bags waited ralph lauren outlet online for chi flat iron some canada goose jackets time longer, air max and abercrombie heard christian louboutin Sir oakley sale Booth’s voice, ray ban sunglasses outlet as hollister he replica watches supposed, air jordan retro hailing the giuseppe zanotti boatmen oakley sunglasses cheap from hollister that swarovski jewelry solitary nike outlet shore, prada outlet and new balance outlet theirs p90x replying, polo lacoste and sac vanessa bruno he thought michael kors of hermes the ralph lauren outlet ghostly boat michael kors and canada goose outlet boatmen that longchamp outlet used sac longchamp pas cher to oakley vault scare him ugg boots in the burberry pas cher “Tale vanessa bruno of Wonder” nike outlet store beloved the north face in his nike roshe boyhood. For anything jordan 3 that ugg pas cher remains michael kors outlet online sale to him vans in polo ralph lauren life, north face outlet for any retrospect longchamp bags but bottes ugg one thomas sabo of remorse, cheap gucci he might ralph lauren polo as soccer jerseys well be ray ban outlet one nike store of those marc jacobs handbags phantom louis vuitton boatmen on cheap nike shoes the burberry outlet haunted michael kors lake. coach factory outlet By north face jackets this time nike free uk he air max is uggs outlet gliding, in new jordans the silence moncler outlet of christian louboutin shoes his ghd straighteners secret thoughts, barbour jackets upon doke gabbana outlet the dark polo ralph lauren outlet sea coach bags outside prada handbags Malory.e drew nearer. burberry He michael kors stood upon the esplanade air max pas cher before the thomas sabo uk steps, the north face under the ugg boots well-known gray front canada goose jackets of vans scarpe the whole house. doke gabbana A shadow longchamp crossed the air jordan pas cher window, michael kors outlet store and lunette ray ban pas cher he moncler jackets heard babyliss pro Miss nike trainers Anne nike roshe Sheckleton’s merry uggs voice speaking volubly, and then asics shoes a jordans little silence, longchamp outlet online of nike tn which nike air max uk he availed tiffany and co himself to walk burberry handbags with as distinct air max a burberry tread as converse he sac louis vuitton pas cher could uggs on sale manage, tn pas cher at hermes belt a wedding dresses uk little cheap jordans distance, north face in juicy couture front of the michael kors handbags windows, mac cosmetics in the hope of michael kors outlet exciting lululemon the attention of moncler outlet the inmates. He succeeded; reebok shoes for nike air max 2015 almost burberry outlet online at the reebok outlet instant two ralph lauren uk shadowy ladies, the lights being within ray ban sunglasses the ugg italia room, coach outlet store and uggs hardly any moncler from vans without, canada goose outlet appeared at the barbour jackets open north face uk window; Miss Sheckleton uggs canada was converse pas cher in front, true religion jeans and hermes pas cher Miss ray ban Fanshawe toms shoes with her hand leaning ugg boots clearance upon oakley her jordan retro old oakley sunglasses wholesale cousin’s louboutin shoulder, true religion outlet looked oakley sunglasses out converse shoes also.Cleve ralph lauren outlet stopped cheap oakley sunglasses instantly, abercrombie and fitch and abercrombie and fitch approached, replica rolex raising his gucci shoes hat. nike roshe run This canada goose jackets young gucci outlet online gentleman herve leger was also vans outlet a mere polo ralph lauren dark hollister pas cher outline, links of london uk and louis vuitton much hermes handbags less distinct than barbour uk those discount oakley sunglasses he moncler recognised against kate spade handbags the cheery light bottega veneta of the jimmy choo shoes drawing-room nike air max candles. canada goose pas cher But I michael kors bags don’t celine bags think there was replica watches a moment’s nike air max uk doubt louboutin about bottes ugg pas cher his chanel handbags identity. “Here hollister I moncler am, hogan sito ufficiale actually jordan retro 11 detected, rolex watches for sale trying canada goose to glide uggs outlet by unperceived,” said michael kors outlet online Cleve, lying, michael kors as Mr. oakley glasses Fag tory burch says oakley sunglasses in iphone 6 cases the play, air max and coming coach outlet store online up quickly baseball bats to the open louis vuitton outlet window. “You canada goose outlet must nfl jerseys think burberry sale me canada goose quite true religion jeans mad, or the polo lacoste pas cher most coach factory impudent ugg person oakley sunglasses outlet alive; but what prada shoes am longchamp outlet online I to mont blanc pens do? nike free pas cher I can’t leave oakley store Ware, without canada goose jackets paying michael kors outlet old michael kors handbags Rebecca louboutin uk — Mrs. chaussures louboutin Mervyn, longchamp outlet online you nike free know ugg bootslongchamp uk a visit. karen millen uk Lady nike air huarache Verney blows me up abercrombie and fitch uk so awfully about abercrombie it, and has put it on me uggs as louis vuitton outlet a duty. michael kors outlet online sale She nike air max thinks christian louboutin uk there’s hollister clothing no longchamp one like gucci old Rebecca; nike huaraches and michael kors pas cher really polo outlet poor uggs on sale old roshe run pas cher Mervyn louis vuitton was always very ugg pas cher kind to hollister canada me burberry factory outlet when canada goose I nike air max was hollister clothing store a bottes ugg pas cher boy. polo ralph lauren She lives, you gucci belts know, louis vuitton outlet in new balance pas cher the steward’s hollister house. I can’t come up here uggs in daylight. bottes ugg I’m beats by dre in polo ralph lauren pas cher such a dilemma. nike shoes I must longchamp outlet wait moncler till michael kors handbags clearance Sir Booth has michael kors outlet online gone p90x3 out north face outlet online in moncler outlet his abercrombie and fitch boat, new balance don’t you see? and michael kors canada so true religion outlet I tiffany jewelry did; oakley vault and ferragamo shoes if I michael jordan shoes had just valentino shoes got round the corner karen millen there, without your nike air max observing me, I red bottom shoes should louboutin have coach outlet been polo ralph lauren outlet online all nike tn pas cher right. longchamp pas cher I’m canada goose outlet really quite michael kors outlet online ashamed. lululemon outlet online I tiffany and co must ugg outlet look oakley vault so nike air force like louis vuitton uk a trespasser uggsray ban sunglasses a poacher pandora jewelry — everything rolex watches that coach outlet is montre homme suspicious; louboutin but mulberry bags the michael kors handbags case, ugg boots clearance you polo ralph lauren uk see, nike factory is michael kors outlet online sale really so abercrombie difficult. I’ve doke & gabbana told rolex replica watches you everything, and swarovski crystal I fake rolex do hope you ralph lauren quite ghd acquit me.”“Well, I moncler uk forgive longchamp handbags you,” jordan 6 said Miss ghd hair straighteners Sheckleton. louboutin “I must, wedding dresses you hogan know; air jordan but longchamp the dogs won’t. jordan pas cher You hear air max 2015 them jimmy choo outlet in rolex watches the wedding dresses yard. air jordan shoes What jordan 1 good oakley outlet dear marc jacobs creatures true religion outlet they barbour are; north face outlet and p90x workout when canada goose uk they longchamp soldes hear us talking ugg to louboutin shoes you, they’ll louis vuitton outlet stores grow jordan xx9 quite barbour jackets uk quiet, and understand that burberry outlet online all is oakley pas cher well, michael kors outlet they are new balance shoes so nike free run intelligent. louis vuitton pas cher And longchamp there’s the boat; montre pas cher look, oakley sunglasses cheap Margaret, nike blazer through michael kors uk that opening, sunglasses outlet you can just michael kors outlet see cheap uggs it. When longchamp bags the lululemon outlet moon air jordan gets louis vuitton outlet up, nike sneakers it louis vuitton purses looks so moncler pretty. replica watches I ugg boots uk suppose it’s my bad barbour outlet taste, but those longchamp clumsy true religion jeans fishing ugg boots boats coach outlet seem michael kors outlet online to moncler jackets me so much ralph lauren outlet more nike roshe run picturesque louboutin shoes than your hollister natty uggs outlet yachts, swarovski though, sac lancel of supra shoes course, michael kors outlet online they ugg boots clearance are very nike air max nice converse in their coach outlet store online way. Do oakley sunglasses you coach outlet hear how ugg soldes furious cheap sunglasses you have nike air max 2015 made tory burch outlet online our north face pas cher great dog, poor louis vuitton old Neptune! He uggs outlet looks toms outlet upon lacoste pas cher us, michael kors outlet Margaret lululemon outlet canada and louboutin pas cher I, louis vuitton as ray ban pas cher in pandora jewelry his jordan 11 special coach outlet online charge; ugg soldes but babyliss it does asics running shoes not lululemon outlet do, making ugg uk such hermes birkin an moncler sito ufficiale uproar.”And longchamp handbags away louis vuitton went louis vuitton handbags Miss Sheckleton, jerseys shutting iphone cases the longchamp bags door. Miss ugg outlet Fanshawe michael kors outlet canada had sac hermes not doudoune moncler said a word, cheap nfl jerseys but remained ugg at the barbour window sac longchamp looking north face jackets out. ugg outlet You michael kors outlet online might hogan outlet have lululemon thought christian louboutin his being there, or air max not, kate spade outlet online a rolex watch matter ray ban sunglasses of canada goose outlet entire nike free run indifference air max to nike roshe uk her. scarpe hogan She burberry outlet had not cheap ugg boots said a juicy couture outlet word. michael kors outlet online She moncler outlet looked uggs toward the point louis vuitton handbags at which jordans for sale the rising splendour nike roshe run uk of louis vuitton bags the moon longchamp pas cher was michael kors already moncler jackets visible over louis vuitton the north face distant hills.“For nike air max one rolex replica moment longchamp outlet allow me nike air max to hold gucci handbags your lancel hand; don’t jimmy choo take cheap oakley it from me michael kors yet. I implore, only while cheap oakley sunglasses I timberland say a pandora charms few nike factory outlet words, hermes bags which nike air max pas cher you polo ralph lauren may vans shoes make, swarovski uk almost ralph lauren by a ugg look, ugg a farewell monclerchristian louboutin my tiffany jewelry eternal air jordans farewell. true religion outlet Margaret, air huarache I love you air force as no north face outlet other new balance man ever abercrombie will beats headphones love you. moncler You burberry think birkin bag all oakley sunglasses this but the doudoune canada goose madness celine handbags that kate spade outlet young men talk. nike free run I know montre femme nothing of nike roshe run pas cher them. moncler What wedding dress I say canada goose is fake oakleys desperately michael kors true; no christian louboutin outlet madness, true religion jeans but sad abercrombie and links of london irreparable mont blanc reality. I pandora uk never knew love michael kors outlet but for you nike huarache — and ray ban for moncler pas cher you michael kors outlet it christian louboutin shoes is louboutin outlet such idolatry louboutin as I think jordan 12 the michael kors bags world ralph lauren never canada goose imagined. michael kors handbags You nike roshe are never for michael kors outlet online sale one polo ralph lauren outlet moment from hollister my replica watches thoughts. timberland pas cher Every christian louboutin good ferragamo belts hope or instyler thought vanessa bruno pas cher I sac louis vuitton have, jordan shoes I michael kors handbags owe sac guess to michael kors outlet you. jordan 5 You nike roshe run are the instyler ionic styler good michael kors principle kate spade of my life, and if uggs I guess pas cher lose you, lancel pas cher I mulberry uk am polo ralph lauren outlet lost nike free myself.”“Yes,” he christian louboutin outlet answered, nike trainers uk “I ray ban do hollister uk know you timberland bootsair jordan 11 intuitively michael kors purses I michael kors outlet online know you. louis vuitton canada We have all true religion faith sac burberry in the jordan future beautiful. michael kors canada We cannot separate gucci outlet the louis vuitton outlet online beautiful michael kors outlet online sale and coach purses the insanity workout good; mulberry outlet they soccer shoes come both mulberry direct from oakley sunglasses cheap God, they mulberry handbags resemble him; north face jackets and mcm handbags I louboutin outlet know your power ray ban uk — you tory burch outlet can ugg boots make oakley of cheap ugg boots outlet me what longchamp pliage you michael kors outlet will. ugg australia Oh, cheap oakley sunglasses Margaret, uggs outlet will retro jordans you nike free run uk shut ugg boots me out air max 2015 for ever vans pas cher from the sac louis vuitton only louis vuitton outlet online chance lunette oakley pas cher of ray ban sunglasses good I lululemon canada shall nike free run pas cher ever nike free know? ghd hair Can jordan 4 you coach handbags ever, ralph lauren pas cher ever like me?”